Missing patient history: how to get a complete record for new and transferring patients
By AllesHealth GmbH ·
A new patient has just moved to the area. She takes "a blood pressure tablet and something for the thyroid", had "an operation on the knee a few years ago" and cannot remember the name of her previous GP's practice, only the town. The MPA hands you an almost empty file. Every practice knows this situation, and it becomes more common when practices take over patients from a colleague who is retiring. This article explains why a missing patient history matters, which Swiss rules apply when you request previous records, and how to organise intake so that the history is complete as quickly as possible.
Why a missing history is a risk
Missing information is not only inconvenient. In a study of 1,614 primary care visits, clinicians reported missing clinical information in 13.6% of visits, and missing information was more likely for new patients, recent immigrants and patients with several conditions [1]. Clinicians considered the gap at least somewhat likely to harm the patient in 44% of the affected visits [1].
Medication is a particular weak point. A systematic review of 22 studies compared the medication histories taken by physicians at hospital admission with comprehensive medication histories: errors occurred in up to 67% of cases. The five studies that explicitly distinguished unintentional errors from intentional changes found that 27% to 54% of patients had at least one medication history error, and that 19% to 75% of the discrepancies were unintentional [5]. These figures come from hospitals, not GP practices, but they show how unreliable a medication history taken from memory alone can be.
Requesting records from the previous doctor
The most complete source is usually the previous practice. In Switzerland, two sets of rules matter here.
Professional secrecy and consent. Doctors and their auxiliary staff are bound by professional secrecy under Art. 321 of the Swiss Criminal Code [3]. According to the FDPIC, doctors may not disclose such data without the patient's consent; under certain conditions, disclosure without consent is permitted on the basis of an authorisation from a superior or supervisory authority, or for research purposes [3]. Secrecy also applies between doctors: being bound by professional secrecy themselves does not entitle colleagues to receive the information [3]. When a patient changes practice, consent is the usual route. In practice, this means: ask the patient to sign a short, specific request that names the previous practice, your practice and the documents you need, and send it with your request.
The patient's right of access. Under the revised Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP), patients can ask any practice whether and which personal data it holds about them. According to the FDPIC, no reason has to be given, and the information is generally provided free of charge within 30 days; fees of up to CHF 300 can only be charged for requests that involve a disproportionate effort [2]. A request sent by post should include a copy of an official identity document [2]. Patients can therefore also obtain a copy of their own record and bring it along. This route is useful when the previous practice is slow to respond or the patient wants their own copy anyway.
How long previous records are kept. Minimum retention periods for medical records are set by cantonal law and differ between cantons. Because of the limitation period in liability law, the FMH states that a medical record should be kept for 20 years after the end of the treatment [4]. Older records may therefore still exist even if the practice has closed or changed hands; it is worth asking who took over the archive. Check the rules of your own canton for your practice's records.
The EPD as an additional source
If the patient has a Swiss electronic patient record (EPD), it may contain discharge letters, reports or other documents from previous providers. Access is controlled by the patient: a health professional generally needs an access right granted by the patient, and the patient's settings determine which documents are visible; without that right, access is only possible in a medical emergency, and the patient is informed afterwards [6]. MPAs can act on behalf of the responsible professional with the same rights [6]. Ask new patients whether they have an EPD and whether they want to grant your practice access. For more on the current legal situation, see our article on the Swiss electronic patient record.
A practical intake workflow for MPAs and nurses
A clear routine makes sure that every new patient's history is built up in the same way:
- When booking: ask the patient to bring all current medication packs or a medication list, recent reports, vaccination records and the name and address of the previous practice.
- Consent form: at the first visit, have the patient sign a specific consent to request records from the previous practice (and from specialists or hospitals, if relevant). Record which documents were requested and when.
- Send the request promptly. Send it in writing, together with the signed consent, and note a follow-up date. If nothing has arrived after a reasonable time, follow up or suggest that the patient uses their own right of access.
- Structured history: use the same set of questions for every new patient: current problems, previous diagnoses and operations, allergies and intolerances, vaccinations, family history (for example cardiovascular disease, diabetes or cancers in close relatives), social history and lifestyle. A standard form, on paper or in the record, keeps it consistent.
- Medication reconciliation: compare what the patient brings (packs, lists, prescriptions) with what the patient says they actually take, including over-the-counter products. Note discrepancies for the doctor to clarify, then record one agreed medication list.
- Transfer into the record: when previous records arrive, enter the key information (diagnoses, operations, allergies, long-term medication, important results) in structured fields rather than only filing the PDF. Mark what has been checked by the doctor.
- Relatives and carers: for older or dependent patients, record who helps with medication and appointments, with the patient's consent.
What to look for in practice management software (2026)
When choosing software, these questions help with new-patient intake:
- Can the history (diagnoses, allergies, medication, family history) be recorded in structured fields that are visible at every visit?
- Can patients send documents to the practice digitally before their first appointment?
- Can relatives or carers be linked to a patient's account?
- Is the record based on standards such as HL7 FHIR and SNOMED CT, which makes it easier to exchange data later?
- Where is the data hosted, and how are access rights and data protection handled?
How AllesHealth Connect helps
AllesHealth Connect is practice software for GP practices and multi-doctor outpatient clinics, designed in Switzerland. It does not replace the consent and the request to the previous doctor, but it keeps the history in one place once it arrives.
For doctors
- One electronic health record that keeps the patient's history, documentation, prescriptions and reports together, so the picture grows with every document instead of being scattered across folders.
- Built on HL7 FHIR with support for SNOMED CT coding, so diagnoses and findings are stored in a structured way.
- AI-assisted EHR updates (Premium plan), including voice dictation, help you transfer the key points of previous records into the record. The AI drafts and suggests; you review every entry and remain responsible.
- E-prescriptions based on the reconciled medication list.
For nurses and MPAs
- Patients can upload their own documents in Patient Companion, for example a previous medication list or a discharge letter, so fewer papers need to be scanned at the desk.
- Messages with the patient make it easy to ask for missing documents before the first visit.
- Family members and carers can be added in Patient Companion, which helps when a relative manages documents and appointments for a patient.
For patients
- In Patient Companion, the app in your practice's branding, patients have a medical records library with prescriptions, lab reports, imaging and their own uploads, and a health journey that groups reports by condition.
- Medication reminders support patients in taking the agreed medication.
Data of Swiss practices is hosted in Switzerland (Zurich).
Related reading
- Data protection for Swiss medical practices under the revised FADP
- The Swiss electronic patient record (EPD): what medical practices need to know
- Missing lab results, reports and medication lists: why GPs lack health data at the point of care
Try AllesHealth Connect free for 60 days – no setup needed, no credit card: start free or book a demo. See the plans on our pricing page.
#DigitalHealth #ClinicManagement #GPPractice #PatientHistory #NewPatients #DataProtection #MPA #Switzerland
Sources
- Missing clinical information during primary care visits, JAMA (2005)
- Auskunftsrecht, Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner (FDPIC)
- Bekanntgabe von Patientendaten, Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner (FDPIC)
- Leitfaden für die Aufbewahrung und Archivierung (Version 03/2023), FMH Swiss Medical Association (2023)
- Frequency, type and clinical importance of medication history errors at admission to hospital: a systematic review, CMAJ (2005)
- Zugriff & Vertraulichkeit (EPD functions for health professionals), patientendossier.ch (eHealth Suisse) (2026)